The MILF Next Door (Part 12) Gwen’s Return

The emails from Mystery Woman came to a stop. Nate was unsure whether that was because he had been so unresponsive the last few weeks or if Allison was his Mystery Woman. After their hot sex in the casino bar storeroom, Nate hoped it was the latter. Finally expecting answers, Nate looked forward to his next meeting with Allison but she did not return for her regular Wednesday/Sunday visits. When asked, Andrea told him that Allison had moved to Philadelphia to spend time pursuing her computer science degree. Andrea offered some hope to Nate, noting that Allison would likely return to Atlantic City for a weekend soon and who knows? As Andrea had feared, the word got around the casino staff that there was a young new dealer and the cocktail waitresses lined up to flirt with Nate, to proposition him and some even convinced Nate that they were really interested in him, only to move on as soon as they bedded him. Nate soon grew tired of the “no strings attached” nature of these hookups and began to want something more. Still, Nate had gotten a taste of the variety that women had to offer and really had no cause to complain. Nate turned his thoughts to Gwen and prayed that she had not acquired a steady boyfriend while away at Notre Dame. Gwen was returning home soon and Nate was looking forward to a second date, assuming he could get past her father. The only problem was he didn’t have her number or know where she lived. The phone book had a long list of Morales families in the area and Nate had no way to discover which was Gwen’s family. He didn’t think to ask Father Vince.

Gwen returned home to her happy parents, beaming with pride at the news that Gwen had made the University’s Honor Roll with the highest GPA. Even her father could not complain as they asked Gwen about her time at school, conveyed their disappointment that Gwen had been unable to afford a trip home during Thanksgiving, and expressed their joy at her return. Gwen reminded them that she would be home only for 6 weeks before flying back to Indiana to spend another 4 months at Notre Dame. Gwen tried to contact Nate but learned of his busy schedule from Andrea. Fortunately, when Father Vince mentioned Gwen’s return to town, Nate immediately got her number and regretted that he only had Mondays to make time for Gwen. Six dates in six weeks would be all that he would get and Nate was determined to make the most of them. Nate waited until a time when he thought Gwen’s father would likely be at work before placing a call to the Morales home. The phone was answered by Gwen’s mother and Nate introduced himself, asking if Gwen was free to talk. So this was Gwen’s little romance, Gwen’s mom thought, as she urged Gwen to pick up the upstairs extension. As her mom listened downstairs, Nate asked Gwen to attend the local Christmas fair and she asked “Please Mama?” Her mom was a soft touch but told them no more than 3 hours. She would deal with Roberto later.

Nate got her address and picked Gwen up in his new used convertible. He took special care to meet and hug Gwen’s mother, building up some good will. Gwen pretended to be impressed about his car, mocking Nate gently while they held hands together. During the fair, Nate excitedly talked with Gwen about his work and his experiences, omitting any reference to his sexual escapades. In turn, Gwen told Nate about her school, the obsession throughout town with Notre Dame football, her grades and stories about her roommate, excluding any reference to sex as well. Nate felt better with Gwen around and leaned in for a kiss. Gwen could feel his arousal pressing against her body through his jeans, pleased that she could stir such a reaction four months after last seeing him. She pushed her body closer so she could press against his hardness. Nate reached for her breasts but they were in public and Gwen pushed his hands away. “Prim and proper in the streets”, she recited in her mind. It was a great second date and Nate decided not to push his luck. Still, he desired Gwen and could tell from her reactions that she knew it.

And so the game of avoiding Gwen’s father while sneaking Gwen out for dates started, with the help of Gwen’s mother. For their next date, they snuck off to a movie. Nate couldn’t recount a single scene of the movie’s plot since, as soon as the lights went out, he spent his time kissing Gwen, caressing her skin and trying to get a feel of her ample breasts. His kisses were passionately returned and Gwen let him grope her breasts in the dark but slapped his hand when he tried to go further and reach under her bra. Instead, Gwen reached down to his jeans and unzipped his fly, secretly sliding her hand inside while using her fingers to trace and stroke the outline of the bulging cock covered by his briefs. Nate squirmed and nearly came as his body responded to Gwen’s firm handling of the situation. As the movie ended, Gwen quickly removed her hand before the lights came on. Nate regretted not going commando that night and left the movies with a hard on. Gwen suggested that they be somewhere not so public the next time.

For their next date, Nate claimed to be taking Gwen to a Youth group event at the Church but actually drove to the local Lovers Lane . It was empty at the time, being dusk , and Nate leaned in for a kiss. To his surprise, Gwen pushed him back and proceeded to sit on his lap facing him. She kissed with a hunger, with Nate wondering where her inhibitions had gone. Her skirt obstructed his view but he could feel Gwen slide her crotch over his bulging cock trapped in his jeans, grinding on him while she kissed him more passionately. He reached out for her breasts and she gave them willingly to him, letting him squeeze and knead them as she moaned. He unbotttoned her blouse and saw a sheer, nearly transparent bra, showing off her breasts and the hard nipples he so wanted to suck. He could tell that Gwen was getting close to orgasm and rushed to unzip his jeans and get his cock into the action. And that was when two cars entered the area breaking the mood, causing Gwen to close her blouse and climb off his lap. Nate tried to convince Gwen that the other couples wouldn’t mind or even see since they would be busy in their own cars. But they were no longer private and the meek Gwen had replaced the wildcat. Nate returned Gwen to her home, aching with lust.

Nate planned their fourth date with care. A friend in the housekeeping staff offered to get him access to a room at the Tropicana for an hour. Nate planned to finagle some tickets from another co-worker to the Billy Joel concert at the casino and then leave halfway through for an uninterrupted session with Gwen. That’s where Nate made his first mistake. How could he know that Billy Joel was her Mom’s favorite artist? When he told Gwen that he could get free tickets to the Billy Joel concert, Gwen’s mom overheard on the extension and pleaded to come. How could he say no without revealing his true intentions? Burdened with a chaperone, Nate had to behave himself and left the concert with a set of blue balls and the sound of Billy Joel singing “You Catholic girls start much too late” repeating in his head.

It was her mother’s attendance to the concert that tipped Roberto off about Gwen’s dates. He was furious and determined to make sure that there was no hanky-panky on any future dates before Gwen returned to college. His wife chided Roberto, claiming Nate to have been the perfect gentleman. This time, for their fifth date, Nate and Gwen were forced to actually meet for a Youth group event at church. It was fun and Nate got to see the goofy and playful side of Gwen but there was little chance of any action under Father Vince’s supervision. Nate was enjoying every moment with Gwen but he despaired that they would never get another intimate moment.

Their final date occurred at Gwen’s home, at the invitation of Gwen’s father, who asked him to join them for dinner and stay to watch Monday Night Football. Roberto took the opportunity to get to know this young man, who had apparently bewitched his daughter and his wife. Nate survived dinner by dodging every trick question and innuendo made by her dad and played the part of an earnest suitor. Eventually, it was football time and they all went into the family room to watch the playoff game. The TV was placed against the wall near the doorway, with a love seat couch in the middle, the reclining chair for Gwen’s father only a few feet away on the right and her mother’s chair to the left. A China cabinet stood about 4 feet behind the love seat against the back wall. Gwen was allowed to sit with Nate on the couch, under the watchful eyes of her parents.

Roberto had to admit that the boy had passed every test. He seemed interested in the Eagles game and Roberto began to relax as his wife brought him several beers, which Nate smartly declined. It had been a hard few days for Roberto and he was exhausted. By half-time, the Eagles were leading and Gwen’s mom decided to head off to bed with Roberto on his third and final beer. Gwen’s hand slowly crept onto Nate’s lap, tracing her fingers where she thought his cock would be. She did it in part to tease him but to also reward him for putting up with her father. When her Dad’s head began to slump in slumber, Gwen slowly unzipped Nate’s jeans, slipping her hand in and realizing that this time Nate had the foresight to go commando. Naughty Gwen awoke.

Nate sat there in panic as Gwen licked her lips and slowly began an undercover hand job. She put saliva in her hand and greased his pole, grasping it hard and sliding her hand up and down. Nate bit his lower lip to avoid moaning. How could this girl who wouldn’t do anything remotely sexual in public be stroking his cock with her father 5 feet away in the same room? It was arousing and he panicked even more when he wondered what would happen when he shot his load and had to say goodbye to her Dad with a large wet stain in his pants? Nate was certain that this hand-job would be his end. Nate nearly fainted when Gwen’s Dad snorted and re-adjusted in his chair before slightly snoring.

Gwen pulled her hand from his pants and led Nate behind the couch where they were less visible. She pushed him down to the floor and unzipped his pants, releasing his cock which was drooling with pre-cum. And then Naughty Gwen leaned down and took control, licking his cock quietly, stroking it and forcing Nate to suffer his pleasure in silence. She could taste the strawberry lube but said nothing and attacked his manhood with more vigor. It was erotic and unexpected, and Nate forced back the need to immediately orgasm. Naughty Gwen swallowed him whole, a sight to behold as she swirled it in her mouth, occasionally slurping loudly daring her Dad to awaken. So a little battle was waged, with Gwen determined to do her best to bring Nate to orgasm while Nate did his misguided best to delay the inevitable in fear of waking her Dad or spraying his load all over the room, leaving evidence of their sexual romp. Gwen would stroke him hard and fast while Nate closed his eyes and clenched his fists, pushing down the sperm seeking to escape. Gwen doubled her efforts by deep-throating his cock again and sucking as hard as she could, seeing Nate lightly moan and struggle to defeat this advance. It turned Gwen on to see how much control she had over this man whom she lusted after or maybe even loved. Gwen went for broke and used a trick from Andrea, slipping a finger into Nate’s ass and the war was won. Nate exploded in her mouth and spurted and spurted while Gwen swallowed every drop. When Nate finally opened his eyes, he saw Gwen zip up his fly and lead him to the other side of the couch with her Dad still asleep. “So do you think that will hold you over until I return for the summer?”, Gwen asked. Nate nodded vigorously and said “You’re such a naughty girl.” Naughty Gwen smiled her agreement. They then focused on the game and cheered as her father’s beloved Eagles finished off their rival Dallas Cowboys with a field goal to win the NFC Championship 20-7.

The cheer roused her father from his slumber. Gwen said that Nate had to leave for home, and Roberto thanked him for coming while Nate thanked him for letting him cum. Roberto went to bed happy that his beloved Birds were headed to their first Super Bowl appearance and more satisfied that his daughter was returning to school with her virtue intact under his careful supervision. Gwen agreed with her Dad that it was the most satisfying game of the season, thinking “Rule #5 complete” as she went up to bed with plans to furiously masturbate to an orgasm with the lights out.

Author's note: For true Eagles fans, I admit to using some creative liberty by moving the 1981 Eagles victory over Dallas from a Sunday, I pm game to a Monday night match. Go Birds! Crush those Chiefs!

Cumming Soon- Part 13: Pay It Forward